On Colossians – written from where?

A introduction to Colossians typically treats the question of provenance – where was Paul when he wrote Colossians?

The short answer is (1) in prison, and (2) the city is unknown.

Nowadays, scholars seem to care little whether Paul was writing from Rome, Ephesus, or somewhere else. There are some historical questions, like matters of the distance between Rome and Colossae and ease of travel for Onesimus, but it hardly makes a huge impact on the interpretation of the letter (other than when such issues lead to doubting the authorship attribution).

I am quite happy to guess (for it is little more than that) that Paul was in Rome, partly because this is the major tradition of the Church (also manuscripts K and L, for example, actually contain a line reading “written from Rome”). Again, this effects the exegesis little per se, but what I think is more important is that decisions about the place of imprisonment and the dating in association with Acts and his other letters give us a glimpse into the type of imprisonment. One could use the language of imprisonment and there could be a wide range of circumstances associated (from little freedom and choice to a very flexible situation).

Based on Paul’s ability to be in contact with various people, the presumption of collaboration in writing, and some evidence from Acts, I am inclined to think he was in a rather flexible situation – perhaps under house arrest (in Rome? See Acts 28:16). For Paul to “live by himself” does not mean he lived a charmed life. Under guard, he may have even been shackled, which may means that his reference to “chains” (4:18) in Colossians could be literal. Not to mention to mental and emotional stress and trauma of confinement and an uncertain future.

In my commentary, I try to make flesh out how his themes of joy and thanksgiving would have been all the more an act of will as it was an emotion and reaction, given his circumstances. I don’t think it has been explored how Paul’s “prison letters” (Eph, Col, Phil, Phm) are unique among the Pauline corpus precisely because he is under such trying circumstances and is thinking more about death, shame, weakness, and hope.

About these ads

2 thoughts on “On Colossians – written from where?

  1. Nijay, in your earlier post you rightly point out that the authorship of Colossians is disputed, and that you find no compelling argument for or against its authenticity. Yet here, you just proceed on the assumption that it was written by Paul. This simply won’t do, especially as you have not answered the arguments for pseudonymity that I offered.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s